Monday 31 December 2018

MICHAEL OLIVER IS 'REFEREE OF THE YEAR' SAYS NEWSPAPER COLUMNIST

                                                             

MICHAEL Oliver is the Referee of The Year, says columnist Keith Hackett, himself a former outstanding official,  in today's edition of The Daily Telegraph.

Still only 33, the Northumberland official has constantly impressed  since taking his first Premier League match - Birmingham v Blackburn - on August 21, 2010.

Curiously, the last three matches for which he has been in the middle have all ended 5-1 - Cardiff v Man U, Burnley v Everton and and Liverpool v Arsenal.

On Wednesday (January 2) he will be Fourth Official for the match between Huddersfield and Burnley.

He will also be Fourth Official when Newport County host Leicester City in the FA Cup on Sunday. 
























Saturday 29 December 2018

MATCH OFFICIALS FOR FA CUP THIRD ROUND

THE FA has announced the match officials for the Third Round of the Emirates FA Cup.They are as follows (kick-off at 3pm unless otherwise stated):


1 Bolton Wanderers FC v Walsall FC Saturday 5 January
Referee Darren England
Assistant Referees Neil Davies & Daniel Robathan
Fourth Official James Oldham

 
2 Millwall FC v Hull City 2pm, Sunday 6 January
Referee Andy Woolmer
Assistant Referees Ian Cooper & Graham Kane
Fourth Official Robert Whitton

 
3 Gillingham FC v Cardiff City FC Saturday 5 January
Referee Tim Robinson
Assistant Referees James Mainwaring & Samuel (Sam) Lewis
Fourth Official Antony Coggins

 
4 Brentford FC v Oxford United Saturday 5 January
Referee Jeremy Simpson
Assistant Referees Nigel Lugg & Darren Blunden
Fourth Official Christopher O'Donnell

 
5 Sheffield Wednesday FC v Luton Town 12.30pm, Saturday 5 January
Referee Robert Jones
Assistant Referees Jonathan Hunt & Adam Matthews
Fourth Official Daniel Middleton

 
6 Manchester United FC v Reading FC 12.30pm, Saturday 5 January
Referee Stuart Attwell
Assistant Referees Darren Cann & Andrew Garratt
Fourth Official David Coote
VAR Jonathan Moss
AVAR Stephen Child

 

7 Everton FC v Lincoln City FC Saturday 5 January
Referee John Brooks
Assistant Referees Akil Howson & Lee Venamore
Fourth Official Michael Salisbury

 

8 Tranmere Rovers FC v Tottenham Hotspur 7.45pm, Friday 4 January
Referee Andre Marriner
Assistant Referees Edward Smart & Marc Perry
Fourth Official Paul Tierney

 
9 Preston North End FC v Doncaster Rovers FC 2pm, Sunday 6 January
Referee Andy Davies
Assistant Referees Adam Crysell & Billy Smallwood
Fourth Official Barry Lamb

 

10 Newcastle United FC v Blackburn Rovers FC 5.30pm, Saturday 5 January
Referee Kevin Friend
Assistant Referees Matthew Wilkes & Adrian Holmes
Fourth Official Martin Coy
VAR Craig Pawson
AVAR Simon Bennett

 
11 Chelsea v Nottingham Forest FC Saturday 5 January
Referee Andrew Madley
Assistant Referees Timothy Wood & Daniel Leach
Fourth Official Darren Drysdale

 

12 Crystal Palace FC v Grimsby Town FC 5.30pm, Saturday 5 January
Referee Martin Atkinson
Assistant Referees Harry Lennard & Lee Betts
Fourth Official John Busby
VAR Jonathan Moss
AVAR Gary Beswick

 
13 Derby County FC v Southampton FC Saturday 5 January
Referee Oliver Langford
Assistant Referees Andrew Fox & Shaun Hudson
Fourth Official Neil Hair

 

14 Accrington Stanley FC v Ipswich Town FC Saturday 5 January
Referee Dean Whitestone
Assistant Referees Matthew Jones & Wayne Grunnill
Fourth Official Steven Copeland

 
15 Bristol City FC v Huddersfield Town FC 5.30pm, Saturday 5 January
Referee Peter Bankes
Assistant Referees Nick Greenhalgh & Matt Foley
Fourth Official Kevin Johnson

 

16 Newport County AFC v Leicester City FC 4.30pm, Sunday 6 January
Referee Christopher Kavanagh
Assistant Referees Sian Massey-Ellis & Dan Cook
Fourth Official Michael Oliver

 
17 Fulham v Oldham Athletic FC 2pm, Sunday 6 January
Referee Anthony Taylor
Assistant Referees Gary Beswick & Simon Bennett
Fourth Official Lee Swabey
VAR Lee Probert
AVAR Ian Hussin

 
18 Shrewsbury Town FC v Stoke City FC 12.30pm, Saturday 5 January
Referee David Webb
Assistant Referees Paul Hodskinson & John Flynn
Fourth Official Simon Mather

 
19 Blackpool FC v Arsenal 5.30pm, Saturday 5 January
Referee Michael Dean
Assistant Referees Michael McDonough & Andrew Halliday
Fourth Official Paul Tierney

 
20 Manchester City FC v Rotherham United FC 2pm, Sunday 6 January
Referee David Coote
Assistant Referees Peter Kirkup & Simon Long
Fourth Official Paul Marsden
VAR Lee Mason
AVAR Derek Eaton

 
21 AFC Bournemouth v Brighton & Hove Albion FC 12.30pm, Saturday 5 January
Referee Michael Oliver
Assistant Referees Adam Nunn & Ian Hussin
Fourth Official Craig Hicks
VAR Craig Pawson
AVAR Sian Massey-Ellis

 

22 West Ham United v Birmingham City FC 12.30pm, Saturday 5 January
Referee Roger East
Assistant Referees Scott Ledger & Derek Eaton
Fourth Official Alan Young
VAR Lee Probert
AVAR Constantine Hatzidakis

 

23 Woking FC v Watford FC 2pm, Sunday 6 January
Referee Graham Scott
Assistant Referees Stephen Child & Nick Hopton
Fourth Official Roger East

 
24 Burnley FC v Barnsley FC 12.30pm, Saturday 5 January
Referee Simon Hooper
Assistant Referees Simon Beck & Richard West
Fourth Official Graham Salisbury
VAR Lee Mason
AVAR Dan Cook

 
25 Queens Park Rangers FC v Leeds United AFC 2pm, Sunday 6 January
Referee Geoff Eltringham
Assistant Referees Dean Treleaven & Adrian Waters
Fourth Official David Rock

 
26 Sheffield United FC v Barnet FC 2pm, Sunday 6 January
Referee Tony Harrington
Assistant Referees Mark Dwyer & Michael George
Fourth Official Leigh Doughty

 
27 Norwich City FC v Portsmouth FC 5.30pm, Saturday 5 January
Referee Darren Bond
Assistant Referees Mark Jones & Robert Merchant
Fourth Official Dean Skipper

 

28 Fleetwood Town FC v AFC Wimbledon Saturday 5 January
Referee Ross Joyce
Assistant Referees Grant Taylor & Darren Wilding
Fourth Official Benjamin Speedie

 
29 West Bromwich Albion FC v Wigan Athletic FC 12.30pm, Saturday 5 January
Referee Keith Stroud
Assistant Referees Steven Meredith & Mark Pottage
Fourth Official Josh Smith

 
30 Middlesbrough v Peterborough United FC Saturday 5 January
Referee James Linington
Assistant Referees Matthew McGrath & Philip Dermott
Fourth Official Andrew Miller

 
31 Wolverhampton Wanderers FC v Liverpool FC 7.45pm, Monday 7 January
Referee Paul Tierney
Assistant Referees Constantine Hatzidakis & Stuart Burt
Fourth Official Andre Marriner
VAR Anthony Taylor
AVAR Harry Lennard

 
32 Aston Villa FC v Swansea City FC Saturday 5 January
Referee Gavin Ward
Assistant Referees Mark Russell & Geoffrey Russell
Fourth Official Samuel Allison

Friday 28 December 2018

BOOK OF THE YEAR: HOW TO BE A FOOTBALLER by PETER CROUCH



                                                           
 "OI, ref , this kid's too old. Get this lanky joke off!"



Ever since he was playing schoolboy football, Peter Crouch has been a target of attention - often unwelcome - because of his height



Breaking into professional football and, by now 6ft 7in, he had to get used to chants from the stands.



"Freak, freak, freak! Does the circus know you're here?"



And, of course, much of it has been far, far worse - either to his face or via social media.



On one occasion, he was spotted by a group of 30 lads on a stag party while he was waiting in the departure lounge  at  Manchester Airport to take a flight to Ibiza for a short break  to Ibiza with his partner (now his wife), Abbey.



Some of the abuse was so vitriolic - and frightening to Abbey - that they decided to vacate the flight, drive to London and catch a flight from Heathrow the next day. 

Another time, he was "cracked in the face" at a nightclub while carrying a tray of drinks from the bar to his friends. His assailant fled the scene and was never apprehended.


These have been the downsides of being a professional footballer, but, during an impressive playing career, Crouch has taken it all in his (long) stride and, more often than not, seen an amusing side.



And most of it has been immense fun. "I've loved almost every minute of it," he says.



Co-written with Tom Fordyce, How To Be A Footballer is different from the run-of-the-mill football autobiography where the author chronicles his journey through life, sometimes taking the opportunity to settle a few scores en route



In fact, it is not really an autobiography at all - he wrote that 10 years ago.



Instead, it is a whistlestop tour of various facets of the world of football - more about what happens off the pitch than what happens on it.



For instance, Crouch casts his eye over such subjects as tattoos, musical tastes, superstitions, clothes, media interviews, taking penalties  and the team bus - but not referees (he's perhaps

saving that up for another book).



On the subject of transfers, he confesses it is "so cloak-and-dagger that even those at the centre of it aren't really sure what's happening".



He continues: "The only thing you can say with certainty is that there will always be someone, somewhere who is having the wool pulled over their eyes."



It's all written with wry affection in which Crouch is generous to pretty well everyone, even hard-as-nail defenders whose challenges have come close to threatening a career which, incidentally, has taken in such clubs as QPR, Portsmouth, Aston Villa, Norwich, Southampton,


Liverpool, Stoke and Spurs, not to mention caps for England.



Many of his observation are laugh-out-loud funny and he acknowledges the amount of money players are paid is preposterous, almost comically so, resulting in ridiculous extravagances by some players - particularly when it comes to accumulating cars and/or houses.



Crouch makes plenty of jokes at his own expenses - for instance, his sense of outrage when he was charged £250 for a haircut that should have cost no more than £10.



But he also makes some serious points which will strike a chord with fans.



For instance, he describes the fashion of disembarking from the team bus at a matchday ground while wearing headphones as "a crime".



He explains: "This is the moment when you should be thrilling to the presence of the fans.


“Embrace it. Don't shun the very people who pay your wages."



He is also unimpressed by players (take a bow, Thierry Henry and Romelu Lukaku) who fail to celebrate after scoring.



"It looks a little arsey,"he writes. "If you don’t enjoy scoring goals, there's something wrong in your internal circuitry."



"The non-celebration ruins it for the fans. Hang on: is he offside or something? Why is he not as happy as me?



"Reflect the fans' happiness - don't squash it."



Of goalkeepers, he notes: "They live their lives under the ultimate jeopardy. Do your job and no one cares -  make one mistake and you kill your team.



"You will be remembered not for your best save but for your worst mistake."



How To Be A Footballer is published at £20 by Ebury Press and available wherever books are sold.








Thursday 27 December 2018

THE OFFICIAL WHO FORGOT HIS BOOTS

                                                                

From The Daily Telegraph - December 27, 2018. In the season of goodwill to all men - even to match officials -  you'd have thought one of the two clubs could have saved Mr Karaivanov's blushes by lending him a pair.

Thursday 20 December 2018

SPORTING MEMORIES - AND MORE - OF SKY TV PRESENTER MARK AUSTIN

 

 FOLLOWING a long and illustrious career with the BBC, ITV and now Sky TV, Mark Austin is a well-known face on TV screens in the UK.

Currently a studio-based  anchor man, Austin has worked in numerous war zones, including Iraq, Rwanda and Mogadishu.

But many of the early years of his life in the media were spent  as a sports correspondent, covering top events at Lords, Twickenham, Aintree, Wimbledon and overseas (including cricket tours and the Olympics).

Now in his newly-published book, And Thank You For Watching, he has recounted many of his most memorable experiences.

One amusing time came in 1990 when he was covering the England World Cup campaign in Italy.    


When he and his film crew arrived at their hotel in Naples for the match against Cameroon, the receptionist had no record of a booking under the name "Austin" and the premises were now
fully booked.

As they set off, dejected,  in search for another hotel, the receptionist called after them: "We have a booking tonight for a Mr Stin - Marco Stin."

Recalls the author: "The crew called me Marco for the rest of the trip!"

By complete contrast, Austin's experiences also included covering the Hillsborough tragedy of  the previous year.

He recalls: "As a sports correspondent you don't expect to turn up at a football ground to find scores of bodies lying on the floor of a gymnasium  that has become a makeshift mortuary.

"It was a story that was, in the most tragic way imaginable, to sum everything that was English football in the 80s - poor policing, inadequate and dangerous terracing and fans fenced in like animals".

This excellent memoir is published at £20 by Atlantic Books and available wherever books are sold.




See also:
https://www.blogger.com/blogger.g?blogID=7832848842000861961#editor/target=post;postID=4359045187656490023;onPublishedMenu=allposts;onClosedMenu=allposts;postNum=0;src=link
 

Monday 15 January 2018

MANAGER BACKTRACKS AFTER "SHOOT REFS" RANT

  

THE manager of Doncaster Rovers. Darren Ferguson (pictured), faces sanctions from the football authorities over ill-considered comments he made following his club's home draw with  Plymouth Argyle on Saturday.

The 45-year-old  claimed his side were denied "a blatant penalty" and, when asked what he would like the Football Association to do about  referees, he said "shoot them".

Mr Ferguson believes  fitness standards fall short in some referees, and he was aggrieved that the officials appeared to be laughing after the final whistle.

On Monday, he backtracked with a statement made through the club's website

 “When asked after the game what I personally could do to raise standards, I said: ‘What can I do? Shoot them?"

Although clear to everyone in the room that my comment was a tongue-in-cheek response, it is worth clarifying my comments were borne out of frustration and I absolutely do not advocate violence against officials. 

“I am sorry for that comment and regret the wording, but, as was clear from my post-match comments, I felt the referee got some decisions wrong at key moments in the game.



“Referees have a tough job and I have a lot of respect for the challenges they face, but I would like to see more done to raise standards across the board and give them the best chance of getting decisions right.”

Ferguson's comments and subsequent apology have been noted by the EFL and his remarks passed on by the Professional Game Match Officials Limited to the FA for consideration. 

An EFL spokesman commented: ""Managers and officials are given guidance each season so that they are fully aware of their responsibilities in regard to commenting on match officials and their performance." 

The man in the middle was Andy Haines who is on record as saying he likes  to referee "with a smile on his face"


Wednesday 10 January 2018

FERGUSON SAW THE FUNNY SIDE OF HIS SOVIET SIGNING'S EARLY EXPERIMENT WITH LANGUAGE


Intriguing memoirs of globetrotting footballer
                                                     
              SOME RUSSIAN REFEREES WERE 'ON THE LOOKOUT FOR MONEY'


COULD playing chess make British managers and footballers more capable in their work?

Yes, according to Andrei Kanchelskis who enjoyed an illustrious career at Manchester United, Manchester City, Everton and Glasgow Rangers, plus clubs in Russia, Italy and Saudi, before taking up management himself.


In his excellent autobiography, Russian Winters, he writes: "Chess teaches you a lot about tactics and lateral thinking."


The book contains many fascinating insights and anecdotes, not just about his playing experiences but also about how he (and his family) adapted to living in different cultures where different languages are spoken.


On his arrival in Manchester, he  picked up a mischievous tip from  teammates about how he should address manager Alex Ferguson.


On meeting him in a corridor, the player startled his new boss with the greeting: "F- off, Scottish bastard."


Luckily, Ferguson twigged what had happened and saw the funny side.


Among other revelations in the fast-moving narrative, is that, before matches, Paul Ince  used to take a "little swig of brandy to settle himself for the game ahead".


Kanchelskis was the player nearest to  the infamous incident  when his colleague, Eric Cantona, aimed a kung-fu kick at a fan  after having been sent off for lashing out at  a tight-marking  opponent, Richard Shaw, in a match at Crystal Palace (where Alan Wilkie was the referee).


Says the author: "Cantona's opponents tried everything they could to needle him - they wanted him react, and generally they would get what they wanted . . .in January, 1995, at Crystal Palace, they hit the jackpot."

Selhurst Park - scene of the Cantona kung-fu incident
 
He reckons Cantona's suspension for the rest of the season probably cost his club the Premier League title.

Kanchelskis was released by Manchester United after his manager apparently became unhappy at his habit of not lifting his head when running with the ball, his indifferent  crossing and his lack of understanding on the English game.


The departing player mostly admired Ferguson's management style, but, despite playing alongside stars such as David Beckham and Ryan Giggs during what was an illustrious period for Manchester  United, he was happier after being transferred to Everton, managed by Joe Royle with whom  he got on well.


"He comments: "I didn't win a trophy in my 18 months at Everton, but I probably  enjoyed my football at Goodison Park more than anywhere else."


In his comparison of the British game and that in Italy, the author offers the view  that, tactically, Italian  defenders tend to be "more astute than their English counterparts"who are "physically strong but very weak when it came to knowing where to position themselves".

On the whole, Kanchelskis, now 49, preferred the pace, dynamism and physicality of the game in England to that in Italy where matches were constantly interrupted by players diving, feigning injury and the ref's whistle "shrilling every few minutes".


In Britain, some of his teammates  regularly used to visit  McDonald's restaurants, but when, as a  player at Fiorentina (his manager was Claudio Ranieri), he took his son, Andrei, to one, the author landed himself in hot water with the club hierarchy even though he had ordered nothing for himself.


After someone reported him to his club, he was contacted the next day by the technical  director who told him: "No Fiorentina player goes to McDonald's - ever."


During his spell in Saudi, Kanchelskis understandably declined an invitation  to watch an after-prayers public beheading in Riyadh's Deera Square (known gruesomely as "Chop-chop square") of 18 Filipinos who had been convicted of drug trafficking.


The book contains much intriguing material on  what it was like to grow up in the Soviet Union (he was born in what is now the independent state of Ukraine), and the author notes wryly that, when he came to England, the only knowledge  people seemed to have of his country came from Bond movies. 


For visitors to the country, he offers the advice: "Russian beer is very cheap and not very good - you're better off buying imported German lager rather than Baltika, the biggest brand of Russian beer brewed in St Petersburg."


In recent years, the author has been managing clubs in Russia where he claims some referees were  "on the lookout for money". 


He continues: "One asked me how much I was prepared to pay to settle the result - I sent him away."


What was the name of the referee? Did he report the matter to the governing body? Kanchelskis does not say.


Mostly, the seems to have enjoyed his globetrotting footballing life but there have been tragedies along the way - notably  his wife Inna's loss of their first baby which, he says, temporarily "killed his desire for the game".


Subsequently, the couple had two children, but he was heartbroken  when Inna left him for a Russian pop star whom she had met after one of his concerts.


"I was shocked by what happened,"he recounts. "Stunned. I did not see it coming."


One thing that shines through in this superb book (co-written with consummate  skill by journalist Tim Rich) is the eminent good sense of the author who now lives in Moscow.


He has made a fortune out of being a football star, but he says modestly: "The money doesn't change you - it doesn't alter who you are.


"The money is a mask. It's  there for you to hide behind."

Russian Dreams is published at £20 by deCoubertin Books, a dynamic British publishing house which has steadily built up a most impressive list of sports titles.
www.decoubertin.co.uk


 

Saturday 6 January 2018

MIKE RILEY IN PRE-TRIAL BRIEFING TO BRIGHTON AND PALACE PLAYERS AND OFFICIALS



Mike Riley - briefings to Brighton and Palace
 REFEREES’ boss Mike Riley has updated players and management at both Brighton and Crystal Palace about how the Video Assistant Referee system will operate in advance of the clubs' 3rd Round FA Cup match on January 8.

Although the system has been used in other countries, Monday’s trial will represent a first in an English football competition.

It has been tweaked and re-tweaked at least times by the technical director of the International Football Association Board, David Elleray, a former top-flight referee whose bookish credentials were established first as a Geography student at Oxford University, then in a long career as a master at uppercrust public school Harrow (where, in earlier times, Sir Winston Churchill had been a pupil).

The two VARs for the Brighton-Palace match will be Premier League referee Neil Swarbrick (below) and assistant referee Peter Kirkup who has many years’ experience running the line in top-flight football..


The intention is for their intervention to be minimal (or even non-existent)  - only deployed in the following situations:
  
* Goals and whether there was a violation during the build up 
* Penalty decisions 
* Red card decisions (note that second yellow cards are not reviewable) 
* Mistaken identity in awarding a red or yellow card

According to FIFA regulations, the process begins with the video assistant referee and the assistant video assistant referee  reviewing the play in question on a bank of monitors in the video operation room  with the assistance of a replay operator.

This can be triggered by the referee requesting the review or by the VAR conducting a "check" to see if he or she should recommend a review to the referee. 

If the VAR finds nothing during the check, then communication with the referee is unnecessary, which is called a "silent check".

 If the VAR believes there has been a potential clear error, he or she will contact the referee with that judgment. 

The referee can then either (a) change the call on the advice of the VAR or (b) conduct an on-field review  by going to a designated spot on the sideline, called the referee review area , to review the video  or (c) decide that he/she is confident in the original call and not conduct a review. 

The referee is allowed to stop play to reverse a call or conduct a review  but is not supposed to do so when either team is engaged in good attacking  situation.

The official signal for a video review is by the referee making the outline of a rectangle with his index fingers (indicating a video screen). 

However, for most, if not all, of the Brighton-Palace match, it will be business as usual for in-the-middle  referee  Andre Marriner (below) and his assistants, Scott Ledger and Richard West.

                                        
Riley has insisted that, in the event of  the VAR becoming involved, players and management must not seek to harangue Mr Marriner about what decision he should reach.

If they do so, they will face the prospect of sanctions.

The regulation states:" Players who demand a video review by making the rectangle motion are to be cautioned with a yellow card. 

"Players who enter the area where the referee conducts a review are also to be cautioned with a yellow card, and team officials who do so are to be dismissed." 

Palace manager Roy Hodgson has expressed cautious optimism about VAR and its capacity to eliminate "clear miscarriages of justice".

However, he believes it will probably need some "honing" before it can demonstrate its long-term worth.

He commented: "I am not yet convinced that it will make things any better for referee - it might even make them more difficult."

Today's Referee comments: As with many,  the Palace manager makes the mistake of hoping for "justice" to prevail in matches. Football is not a court of law - it is a game and, as such, subject to all sorts of  twists of fortune (just and unjust), not just the  whims of refereeing decisions. But the professional game seems intent of  making things ever more complicated. There is a real risk that VAR will generate more controversies than those it resolved. Whatever happened to the principle that players (and managers) should accept as final the referee's decision - whether they agreed with it or not? Alas, the spirit of sporstmanship  seems to belong to a  bygone age. And football is surely  the worse for it.

Wednesday 3 January 2018

RANT AT REFEREE MIKE DEAN COULD PROVE COSTLY FOR ARSENAL BOSS


Mike Dean - took flak from Wenger

                                                  
THE  waspIsh response of Arsenal manager Arsene Wenger to referee Mike Dean’s  award of a late penalty to West Bromwich Albion  in the match on December 31, 2017,could land him with a hefty fine, a touchline  ban and possibly even tougher sanctions.

A three-man  FA tribunal will reach its verdict later this month at a hearing which will assess allegations that Wenger swore at the referee and questioned his integrity/competence  in the wake of the match which ended 1-1.

It does not help his cause that Wenger has form.

In the match between Arsenal and Burnley, played on January 22 last year, he was involved in an altercation with fourth official Anthony Taylor (the referee was Jon Moss) which resulted in his being fined £25,000, banned from the touchline for four months and warned about his future conduct.

On that occasion, his previous good behaviour worked in his favour, but at the forthcoming hearing, he will appear with a blemished record

The minutes of the last hearing have been published by the FA at:
http://www.thefa.com/-/media/thefacom-new/Files/Rules-and-Regulations/2016-17/Written-Reasons/the-fa-v-arsene-wenger-written-reasons-2017-final.ashx

Ironically, the referee for Arsenal’s match v
Chelsea this evening (January 3, 2018) is Anthony Taylor - the same official whom he swore at and shoved just under 12 months ago.



Monday 1 January 2018

REFEREE WAS ‘SUCCESSFULLY DECEIVED’ BY EVERTON PLAYER SAYS FA TRIBUNAL



THE FA has published its findings into an incident in the match between Crystal Palace and Everton on November 18 in which referee Anthony Taylor (pictured) awarded a penalty to the visiting side.

A three-man panel chaired by former Blackburn Rovers player, Stuart Ripley, now a solicitor, ruled that Oumar Niasse of Everton FC “exaggerated” his fall to gain the decision.

Niasse’s punishment was a two-match ban.

Below are the findings of the panel after the FA brought a charge of misconduct against Oumar Niasse.


Regulatory Commission Decision

1.
These are the written reasons for a decision made by an Independent Regulatory Commission which sat on Wednesday 22 November, 2017.

2.
The Commission members were Mr S.Ripley (Chairman), Mr P. Raven and Mr. M. Johnson.

3.
Mr. M. Ives of the FA Judicial Services Department acted as Secretary to the Regulatory Commission.

4.
Mr Niasse was charged by The FA with misconduct for a breach of FA Rule E3.

The FA alleged that, in or around the 5th minute of the Crystal Palace FC v Everton FC, Premier League Fixture on 18th November 2017, Mr Niasse committed a clear act of simulation which led to a penalty being awarded and that his behaviour amounted to improper conduct.

5.
Mr Niasse denied the charge by way of The FA’s Disciplinary Proceedings Reply Form, dated 21st November 2017and requested that documentation be put before the Regulatory Commission.

6.
The FA relied on Email correspondence between Mr. N.Dutton of the FA’s Regulation Department and the threeSimulation Panel Members, dated  20th November 2017; the Guidance for Panel Members; and Video clips of the incident.

7.
Everton FC submitted a letter from Mr David Harrison, Club Secretary and Head of Football Operations, dated 21st November 2017 and a witness statement from Mr Niasse, dated 21 November 2017 both of which the Commission noted the contents of and footage of the incident from various different angles as to that submitted by the FA.

8.
The Commission noted the comments of the Premier League Delegate whose report on the Match Officials was contained within the documentation submitted by Everton FC who wrote: “The glaring example of simulation was the penalty award on 4 mins against Palace. In my view, Everton’s Niasse has dived to earn his team a penalty and Mr Taylor was successfully deceived. I accept there was contact made by Palace’s Dann. However the contact made is minimal - certainly not enough to make Niasse fall to the ground in the way he did.”

9.
For the avoidance of doubt the Commission also considered the pointsubmitted by the Club that Mr Taylor (the Match Referee) “reiterated his view that he had made the right call because of the contact made.”

10.
In contrast the Commission also noted that the Simulations Panel was composed of an experienced manager and ex-player, another experienced ex-player and an experienced ex-referee who all came to the conclusion that Mr Niasse had committed an act of simulation.

11.
The Commission considered the written guidance provided to the Panel Members which read as follows: For a panel member to conclude that simulation has occurred they must conclude that there is clear and overwhelming evidence.

In judging these incidents, there are five key questions that should beconsidered in the decision-making process.

To identify whether an act of simulation has occurred, the following should be considered:

1. Is there contact between the players involved? Simulation is more likely in cases where a player attempts to deceive the referee when no contact occurred between the players.

2. Is there fair/normal contact between the players, resulting in no offence being committed?

3. Is a player legitimately avoiding contact with his opponent to prevent injury?

4. Has the player initiated the contact between his opponent and himself in order to deceive the referee?

5. Does the player exaggerate the effect of a normal contact challenge in order to deceive the referee?

The Commission were unanimous that the video footage gave clear and overwhelming evidence that the player had exaggerated the effect of a normal contact in order to deceive the referee.

13
The Commission noted that there was contact between Scott Dann and Mr Niasse, but the Commission considered the contact to be normal, fair and expected contact in the situation that arose with Mr Niasse ‘taking on’ Mr Dann.

 14.
The Commission unanimously agree that the nature of the contact made by Scott Dann was minimal in nature and would not have thrown Mr Niasse off balance and knock him down in the way that Mr Niasse portrayed it to have done.

15.
To the minds of the Commission members, the movements of Mr Niasse’s body, in particular the arching of the back and the collapsing of both legs, were simply not consistent with the amount of force exerted upon him by Mr Dann and in exaggerating the effect of the contact made between himself and Mr Dann, Mr Niasse deceived the referee and this led to a penalty being awarded by the referee.

16.
As such the FA charge brought against Mr Niasse for simulation is found proven and therefore Mr Niasse will serve an automatic two-match suspension.

17.
This decision is final and binding and not subject to any further right of appeal.

Stuart Ripley
Regulatory Commission Chairman
22nd November, 2017

* Photo: Courtesy, Match of The Day, BBC-TV